• Review us on Trip Advisor
  • Review us on Urbanspoon
  • Review us on Yelp!

Pleasant surprise

08/23/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars

Very good food, atmosphere, service and food. It needed to be mentioned twice. It will become a regular visit while visiting.

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Delicious! I would recommend going on a...

08/17/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars

Delicious! I would recommend going on a Tuesday night, it's all you can eat pizza and salad for $10 each. The chef just keeps rotating the pizza and salad selection so you get a little of everything....

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Satisfied with the price, server and pizza. Great job.

08/16/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars

We had heard about this place and was recommened by several townspeople. This was the best pizza we have had. The crust was perfect. We could not make up our mind which to try and our server ...

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

AAAAAAAAAAAAAA-MAZING Pizza!!!!!!

08/16/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars

My GF and I went WW rafting on the New river. We're both from out of the area. Pies-n-Pints was recommended by another couple we rafted with. On our way home, we stopped to check it out. The...

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

not impressed

08/11/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 3 of 5 stars

The waitress was not helpful in suggestions, the pizza was just ok, nothing to write home about, and I ordered a pitcher of beer that the menu said costs $6 and they charged me $8. I actually like...

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

AWESOME

08/09/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars

I have never even heard of Pies and Pints and man I'm glad I did! The pizza was really great. I have never wanted to work at a food place before but man I would love to work at your place. Everyone...

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Owner response

07/29/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 0 of 5 stars

So glad to hear we exceeded your expectations and thanks for taking time to write a review.

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

A must!

07/27/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars

Wasn't exspecting anything this good in Fayetteville! Pizza was amazing, service was very good and a good beer selection.

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Tasty pizza with great thin crust. Good...

07/24/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars

Tasty pizza with great thin crust. Good selection of beer at decent prices.

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Incredible food!

07/18/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars

My entire family (all 5 of us) loved our pizzas.... from the Thai pizza, to a pineapple one, to a pepperoni/bacon... everything was absolutely delicious!!! The service was friendly and helpful too. ...

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Owner response

07/14/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 0 of 5 stars

Thank you very much for the great review. We are happy that you had a great Forth of July. Look forward to serving you in the future.

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Fourth of July evening, fireworks and pizza!

07/07/2010

TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars

Short and sweet on this one... We sat in a nice outdoor area, patio and play area for younger kids. Saw the fireworks everyone else spent a mile of walking time to get to... we saw them just...

TripAdvisor Reviews - Pies & Pints Pizzeria Feed Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Doug A. (5/5) on Yelp

09/01/2010

West Virginia's best pizza and good brews. Buffet night on Tuesday's offers a wide assortment.

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Celia M. (5/5) on Yelp

07/08/2010

A restaurant with integrity. Consistently great food and service. The specialty pizzas are all mouthwatering (I'm a local so I think I've tried them all, although they update their menu regularly),…

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Heather C. (4/5) on Yelp

07/06/2010

What a great find! Ate here while passing through on a long car trip after remembering it from our honeymoon 3 years ago. So glad we found it again despite not remembering the name. They were…

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Andy G. (5/5) on Yelp

07/05/2010

We were on a family vacation and a local said we must try Pies and Pints. As a jaded pizza guy from New Haven Connecticut, I've heard this so many times and have always come away underwhelmed. This…

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

beth p. (5/5) on Yelp

05/12/2010

not your ordinary pizza place- from their salads, to their "regular" style pizzas to the truly gourmet- thai, red grape and rosemary, cuban pork...the combinations of flavors are unique, but amazing.…

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Owen S. (5/5) on Yelp

02/17/2010

I concur! Five Stars!!! I am a big whitewater junkie and drive five to eight hours to the area half for the whitewater and half for pies and pints. Delicious pizza and great drinks. Even if you…

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Debra G. (1/5) on Yelp

11/30/2009

Not a good pizza, garlic on pizza very greasy. Nice atmosphere but way overrated

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Pat S. (5/5) on Yelp

11/17/2009

A favorite of my entire family - from the outdoor play equipment for our daughter to the great pies and beer for us.

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Jeff S. (5/5) on Yelp

09/08/2009

Both the pizza and beer are divine. If you are in town, there's really no other place to bother evaluating. JUST GO HERE. I'm not sure where else in WV you'll be able to try several different Rogue…

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria

C S. (5/5) on Yelp

09/07/2009

Was in the area on Labor Day weekend for some kayaking. Our guide recommended this place for dinner after we mentioned we were thinking about going to Pizza Hut out of desperation for comfort food.…

Recent Reviews of Pies & Pints Pizzeria, Fayetteville, WV Pies and Pints Pizzeria
Pies & Pints Pizzeria Pies & Pints Pizzeria on Urbanspoon
Chuck, Jenny and Kelly, June, 25, 2008

Hey Guys! From the beginning, we always knew your place was something special. Thanks for the many smiles and good vibes. Your new spot is fantastic-though it took some getting used to- and we look forward to good times to come.

Anonymous , June 30, 2008

I ate here last summer with friends we all got different pizzas and shared. yum I am looking forward to my next visit this summer.

Catherine Saunders - Ms. , July 6, 2008

Ordered two large pies to carry out. Great food, worth the price. I will try the All You Can Eat Buffet soon.

Food - "Tasty" , July 7, 2008

Hey Guys:
My husband and I consider ourselves the food critics. The food was delicious the atmosphere was great. The only problem that we incurred was the drinks. We all had soda. No where on your menu did it state you had to pay for refills. I was shocked when we received the bill. I wanted my drink to go and they recharged me for another drink!!! Most places you do receive free refills. I sure this does not effect your business due to your food being "delicious". We really, really, enjoyed ourselves. We will be back.

Charlotte Harrah , July 14, 2008

I always look forward to visiting WV in hopes the suggestion is made by someone that we go to Pies & Pints to eat. Someone usually does suggest it. You have by far the best pizza I have ever eaten! Looking forward to my next visit! Charlotte Harrah

Tim M - Great site, my friends and I , July 21, 2008

I was not aware how great your place looks, I will check it out ASAP!!!
Thanks, Tim
WVstreets.com

Rich from St Pete , July 22, 2008

One of the wait staff talked me into the red grape pizza and I have been craving it ever since. It might even be worth a trip up from Florida.

Michael Morace , August 20, 2008

Hi everybody. just want to say you guys did an outstanding job on the website and the new location, it is incredible. I can not wait to get back out there for some awsome food,great people,and a full list of beer!!

The Loves - Love!!! , August 24, 2008

We have went to Pies and Pints over 50 times I'd say. The food is great, and the atmosphere is even better. The black bean pie is the best pizza in the world!!! I love you guys so much!!!

Roberta Nolte - Great Food!! , October 4, 2008

My husband and I traveled to Fayetteville today expressly to try Pies and Pints. We were NOT disappointed.
He had the Turkey Club and I had the Cuban and I have to tell you, we are both so sleepy and not in the least hungry yet and it's been almost 5 hours!
The food was delicious! The service was wonderful!

Boom and Suzanne , October 4, 2008

We visited your place on a poker run from Charleston this past summer and didn't want to leave. The food was awesome and you have a great selection of beer. We are planning our next visit to the area and yes we will definitely be there a few times for some pies and pints.

Rachel P , October 21, 2008

P the food is awesome. My husband and I were up last weekend to hike and ate here for dinner. We had the best time eating pizza and trying all kinds of different beer.
We LOVE it!!!

Rick Random P , October 23, 2008

My wife and were visiting relatives during Bridge Day Weekend. On Monday we slipped away from the crowd to have supper at Pies and Pints. What a treat! Your pies compete successfully with Elizabeth's in Greenville, DE and The Cabin in Bath, ME. My White Pie was amazing, especially with the whole roasted garlic cloves and the assortment of cheeses. Melissa really liked her Grape Pie, too. We washed them down with a couple of Nut Brown ales. Dee-lish, as they say.
Continued success!

Marsha - Ohio Girls!! , November 7, 2008

woohoo: We love you guys!!! Your website looks fantastic! We are "ones who drive miles just to eat your pizza"!!! Every year my home girls from Ohio, and me down here in South Carolina meet half way in Fayetville for our "Girls Weekend" and our favorite and MUST stop is Pies and Pints!! GET SOME!!

William Mullins - Sound Ideas Inc. , January 8,2009

Great food, great atmosphere, great website! Pies and Pints has probably some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. We always have great service every time we attend and the food is always good. Keep up the good work!

Jenna - teacher, raft guide, natl. sno , March 13,2009

I was visiting your site to get an address, but i couldn't resist telling you that when I was out of the country in Africa, and the following year in Nepal, the food I missed from home and CRAVED was your Mushroom Garlic Pie.
LOVE IT!!!!

Crystal Tolley - Pies 'n Pints ROCKS! , March 22,2009

My husband and I had the pleasure of enjoying quiet possibly the best pizza we've ever had at your establishment! The food was great and the service was excellent! Everyone made it a point to ensure our dining experience was the best it could be. We will definitely be back! Keep up the good work! :)

Prakash Roy , April 3,2009

Hi Guys, I have lived in NY, NJ for 11 years. Been to almost all big cities in USA. Have never tested this many veriety of wonderful pizza ever!!!!!!

Erin Shrimpton , May 14, 2009

:cheer: We travel to Fayetteville once a year from Florida for 2 reasons, #1 being your great pizzas.2nd of all is rafting. Your pizzas are the best we have ever had in all of our travels, Europe or the US. See you this September